The Story of BRCA1 and BRCA2

Perhaps the best-known villain in cancer genetics, tests for inherited mutations in the BRCA genes are now front and center, while acquired mutations are also making trouble for even more people.

     BRCA1-2 Mutations at a Glance

  1. Involved in: Breast cancer, ovarian cancer, male breast cancer, pancreatic cancer, prostate cancer, and certain other cancers.
  2. Testing requires: a blood or saliva sample.
  3. Prognosis: High likelihood for women to developing certain cancers, particularly breast and ovarian cancers, at unusually young ages. In women with a BRCA1 and BRCA2 mutation who already have breast cancer, breast cancer is more likely to recur. Women with a BRCA1 mutation are more likely to develop triple-negative cancer, which has poorer prognosis than other strains of breast cancer.
  4. Treatment: Healthy women with an inherited BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutation can undergo enhanced surveillance, chemoprevention, or preventive removal of breasts and ovaries. Some studies suggest that cisplatin and PARP inhibitors are effective against cancer cells with BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutations.

What do Angelina Jolie, Sheryl Crow, and Christina Applegate have in common? Aside from being awesome women in entertainment, all three have BRCA mutations that have impacted their lives. Sheryl Crow and Christina Applegate discovered their BRCA mutations after being diagnosed with breast cancer, while Jolie found out her status while she was still healthy, and chose preventive breast removal. In learning her BRCA status, Jolie joined the ranks of the new class of “previvors,” survivors of a family predisposition to cancer.

BRCA is not entirely a story of predisposition, however. While some patients are born with BRCA mutations that could increase their susceptibility to cancer, others develop BRCA mutations as a part of their cancer. Half, if not more, of these mutations occur this way. Whether acquired or inherited, BRCA mutations can be a point of vulnerability for a cancer to certain new drugs. This story will describe the importance of BRCA for both predisposition and for cancer treatment strategies.

BRCA and Cancer Predisposition

For centuries, doctors had suspected that breast cancer might run in families. In 1866 Parisian surgeon Paul Broca made a chart of his wife’s family, since of her 26 adult relatives, fifteen of them had developed or died of cancer. Broca’s chart was one of the first to trace a breast cancer family. Broca was convinced that cancer could be inherited, but couldn’t unravel how. The thorny problem wouldn’t be solved for more than 100 years, until theories of heredity and genetics, the discovery of cellular DNA, and the means to sequence such DNA could be uncovered.

In 1990, California-based scientist Mary-Claire King fired the starting pistol in the race to uncover the breast cancer gene. Dr. King had already been responsible for DNA-related scientific discoveries—her doctoral thesis proved that human and chimp DNA were almost entirely identical, and her work identifying victims of political violence across the world had helped develop methods of forensic genetics. She turned her remarkable intellect to the task of unraveling the mystery of cancer families in the mid 1970s, and after more than fifteen years of work, in late 1990, she produced evidence that a genetic mutation related to breast cancer risk was hiding out in a certain part of chromosome 17. Scientists around the world took up the search to pinpoint its exact location and in 1994 the Utah-based lab of Myriad Genetics, helmed by scientist Mark Skolnick, identified BRCA1. One year later, Skolnick’s lab in Utah and Sir Mike Stratton’s lab in the UK had identified a second breast cancer gene, known as BRCA2, located on chromosome 13.

BRCA1 and BRCA2 are segments of DNA that every human has in each cell of the body. When BRCA1 and BRCA2 work properly, they are part of the body’s natural defenses against tumor formation. When both copies of BRCA1 or BRCA2 become damaged, cancer can result. In some breast cancer tumors, BRCA1 and BRCA2 have acquired mutations that turn one or both genes off, facilitating the growth of the tumor. Some patients have a flawed copy of BRCA1 or BRCA2, not just in their tumor, but in each cell of their bodies. Such men and women have inherited a flawed copy of BRCA1 or BRCA2 from their parents. Harmful and inherited BRCA1 and BRCA2 mutations raise a woman’s risk of developing breast and ovarian cancer, and raise a man’s risk of developing male breast cancer and prostate cancer. BRCA mutations may also raise risk for cancers in certain additional organs such as the skin, pancreas, uterus and others.

Harmful inherited BRCA mutations are comparatively rare—something like 1 in 400 to 1 in 600 people carry such mutations, though for people with Ashkenazi Jewish heritage these numbers are higher—about 1 in 40 such individuals carry a harmful mutation. Norwegian, Dutch, and Icelandic people also have a higher rate of BRCA mutations. Although BRCA carriers are rare in the general population, they account for about 5 to 10 percent of all breast cancer diagnoses and 15 percent of all ovarian cancer diagnoses. What kind of cancer risk do BRCA inheritors face?
Right now, BRCA1 patients are thought to have a 55 to 65 percent lifetime risk of breast cancer on average and a 39 percent risk of ovarian cancer. BRCA2 patients are thought to have a 45 percent lifetime risk of breast cancer and an 11 to 17 percent risk of ovarian cancer. In addition, BRCA1 and BRCA2 patients experience a two to threefold increase in lifetime pancreatic cancer risk (to about 3 percent and 5 percent lifetime chance for BRCA1 and BRCA2 patients respectively). These numbers are not absolute – as knowledge about the BRCA mutations and the patients who carry them grows, these numbers are changing, and have been largely revised downward in the last few years. But the truth is plain to see: having a BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutation dramatically raises a woman’s risk of developing breast or ovarian cancer.

Not all BRCA mutations are created equal. Because BRCA1 and BRCA2 are gigantic genes, there are many ways for them to go wrong. Each misspelling of a BRCA1 or BRCA2 gene comes with its own unique level of risk. Certain BRCA1 mutations might raise a woman’s risk of developing breast cancer as high 87 percent. Other misspellings are completely benign. The numbers on the chart above are averages for the risk levels of all women with harmful BRCA1 and BRCA2 mutations face. Depending on how rare your BRCA mutation is, your doctor may be able to give you a more accurate risk number.

Every human has a pair of BRCA1 and a pair of BRCA2 genes in each cell of the body – one copy of each from our mom and one from our dads. People with a harmful BRCA mutation start out with one broken copy that may be inherited from either mother or father. If you have one parent with a BRCA mutation, your chance of having the same mutation is 50 percent. BRCA mutations are not the only inherited mutations that affect breast cancer risk. According to the National Cancer Institute, only 20 to 25 percent of hereditary breast cancers involve BRCA mutations. Other mutations that can affect breast cancer risk include TP53, CHEK2, ATM, and PALB2.

Malfunctioning proteins produced by mutated BRCA genes cannot repair damaged cells

Researchers have identified thousands of mutations in the BRCA genes. Many, but not all, are associated with an increased risk of cancer. If either or both BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes are altered by a harmful mutation, the proteins usually produced by the genes may not function properly. These malfunctioning proteins are not able to repair damaged DNA or destroy cells if DNA cannot be repaired. As a result, cells are more likely to develop additional genetic alterations that may eventually lead to cancer.

The Biology of BRCA

How does a BRCA mutation—whether inherited or acquired–cause cancer? Well, at core, cancer is a disease of unchecked cell growth. DNA regulates the cell cycle, ensuring that cells reproduce an appropriate number of times and self-destruct when things go wrong. When several crucial segments of DNA get screwed up by viruses, or environmental exposure, or errors that happen during cell replication, then this process is disrupted, and cells may not stop dividing, leading to cancer. A harmful BRCA mutation, on its own, is not enough to cause cancer, rather, it’s the first domino down in a long chain of events that can lead to cancer. People with inherited BRCA1 and BRCA2 mutations get cancer more frequently because they start up with DNA that is already messed up in one place. Just as a house built on two foundation stones—one that is already starting to crumble—would be more likely to have problems than a house built on two solid stones—so too are people with one wonky BRCA gene more likely to develop cancer.

BRCA1 and BRCA2 are known as “tumor suppressors.” They produce proteins that put the brakes on cell replication—when the cell is reproducing, they produce proteins that say “stop!” BRCA1 and BRCA2 are involved in repairing breaks in cellular DNA. When they don’t work right, cellular DNA doesn’t get correctly repaired and may then acquire other mutations that can lead to cancer.

Cancer Treatments that Exploit BRCA Mutations

Mutations in BRCA1 and BRCA2, whilst causative of cancer when inherited can also lead to vulnerabilities of the cancer to certain treatments. The mutation can either be inherited, or just as commonly occur only in the cancer. Because these mutations cause deficiencies in the way the DNA repairs itself, enhancing the damage to DNA can be lethal to cancer cells. Chemotherapies that are called DNA damaging agents, including mytomycin-c and more commonly platinum-based therapies such as cisplatin, carboplatin and oxaliplatin act by causing extensive damage to DNA. Normal cells can repair this damage whereas those that have deficiencies in DNA damage response such as BRCA 1 and BRCA2 mutations cannot. So the healthy cells survive the DNA damaging agents, but the cancer cells die. DNA-damaging chemotherapies can be very effective, but they come with many side effects and they don’t work for everyone.

Another more recent approach to exploiting such characteristics of cancer cells is something called synthetic lethality. This means taking advantage of a mutation in cells that impairs a process, rendering cells with those mutations sensitive to a particular drug. But because the drug effect depends on the mutation, normal cells without that mutation experience no effect or minimal effects. An example of that is the use PARP inhibitors.

Cancer cells with acquired BRCA1 and BRCA2 mutations have an increased dependency on an enzyme called PARP to repair DNA. This is a kind of backup mechanism to normal BRCA function. Drugs that inhibiting PARP in these cancer cells can be lethal, because the cells have no good way to repair DNA. Noncancerous cells nearby have both BRCA1 and BRCA2 and PARP mechanisms to do so. So DNA damaging agents become more lethal to cancer cells if the patient is receiving a PARP inhibitor. Clinical trials are underway, combining PARP inhibitors and DNA damaging agents, to exploit BRCA mutations in many cancer types including pancreatic cancer and lung cancer.

BRCA Predisposition: Testing & Implications

In general, breast cancer related to inherited BRCA-mutations tends to be a little different from breast cancer in the broader population. It is more likely to strike younger women—women who have not yet gone through menopause. Diagnoses in the 30s or even the 20s are not unheard of in BRCA families. In BRCA1 patients, breast cancer is more likely to be “triple negative.” Cancer that is positive for estrogen receptors or progesterone receptors or the HER/neu protein pathway has an Achilles’ heel that doctors can target using particular drugs. Cancer that is triple-negative lacks all of these weaknesses, making it harder to treat. In addition, women with a BRCA mutation and breast cancer have a much higher rate of recurrence in the healthy breast compared to women with non-BRCA related breast cancer.

Testing positive for a BRCA mutation can influence treatment for patients who have cancer. A BRCA-positive breast cancer patient might respond better to certain therapies or be eligible for studies aimed at unraveling the unique weaknesses of BRCA-related cancer. They might also choose preventive removal of the healthy breast or ovaries as part of their treatment. Women who test positive for a BRCA mutation but who do not have cancer have three treatment options:

  • Intensive medical surveillance for breasts and ovaries aimed at catching cancer early
  • Chemoprevention—taking estrogen blockers to lower cancer risk in the short-term but come with a side effect of temporary reversible menopause.
  • Preventive surgery—removal of healthy breasts or ovaries to eliminate possible sources of cancer.

Each of the treatments has benefits and drawbacks. Surveillance is non-invasive, but can be challenging from a psychological and scheduling perspective, as it requires many doctors’ visits and uncertainty around waiting for test results. It also can not prevent cancer, but merely catch it early. Chemoprevention can give patients the immediate relief of reducing cancer risk, but it has intense side effects and is only a temporary solution, as such drugs can only be taken for a limited amount of time, lest the risk of other forms of cancer climb. Surgery permanently lowers risk. Studies show that breast removal dramatically reduces a BRCA woman’s chance of developing breast cancer, and ovarian removal drops the risk of ovarian cancer and halves the risk of breast cancer. But surgery comes at the cost of bodily integrity, and can cause side effects such as loss of fertility and immediate surgical menopause, in the case of ovarian removal, and numb skin and future operations in the cast of breast removal and reconstruction. The decision of which is right for you will likely not be an easy one, and should be made in consultation with doctors, friends, and family who you trust.

Genetic Tests for BRCA Mutations

Some of the most common personal characteristics include:

  • A known BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutation in the family
  • Breast cancer diagnosed at a young age. (Some studies use age 40 years as a cutoff, while others use age
    50 years)
  • Triple-negative breast cancer
  • Two breast cancer diagnoses
  • Breast cancer affecting both breasts (bilateral breast cancer)
  • Breast cancer at any age and one or more close blood relatives with breast cancer who was diagnosed
    under the age of 50; one or more close blood relative with ovarian cancer; or two or more close blood
    relatives with breast cancer or pancreatic cancer at any age
  • One or more family members on the same side of the family with a combination of breast cancer and one or
    more of the following: pancreatic cancer, prostate cancer, sarcoma, adrenocortical carcinoma, brain
    tumors, endometrial cancer, leukemia/lymphoma, thyroid cancer, dermatologic manifestations or
    macrocephaly, polyps of the GI tract, gastric cancer
  • Ovarian cancer
  • Male breast cancer
  • Ashkenazi Jewish ancestry
  • A known BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutation in the family
  • A family member with two or more breast cancer diagnoses or bilateral breast cancer
  • Two or more family members with breast cancer on the same side of the family
  • One or more family members with ovarian cancer on the same side of the family
  • First- or second-degree relative with breast cancer who was diagnosed younger than 45 years old
  • One or more family members on the same side of the family with a combination of breast cancer and one or
    more of the following: pancreatic cancer, prostate cancer, sarcoma, adrenocortical carcinoma, brain
    tumors, endometrial cancer, leukemia/lymphoma, thyroid cancer, dermatologic manifestations or
    macrocephaly, polyps of the GI tract, gastric cancer
  • Male breast cancer
  • Ashkenazi Jewish ancestry

Some of the most common family history characteristics include:

  • A known BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutation in the family
  • A family member with two or more breast cancer diagnoses or bilateral breast cancer
  • Two or more family members with breast cancer on the same side of the family
  • One or more family members with ovarian cancer on the same side of the family
  • First- or second-degree relative with breast cancer who was diagnosed younger than 45 years old
  • One or more family members on the same side of the family with a combination of breast cancer and one or
    more of the following: pancreatic cancer, prostate cancer, sarcoma, adrenocortical carcinoma, brain
    tumors, endometrial cancer, leukemia/lymphoma, thyroid cancer, dermatologic manifestations or
    macrocephaly, polyps of the GI tract, gastric cancer
  • Male breast cancer
  • Ashkenazi Jewish ancestry

These may not capture all personal or family history characteristics. If you think you are a candidate for genetic testing for BRCA mutations, talk to your doctor.

 

Being diagnosed with cancer is an overwhelming experience. Our goal is to help you understand and identify cancer treatment options you might not have found on your own. Get started below and we’ll partner with you to determine your next step.

© 2016 | Cure Forward. All rights reserved.

©2017 Cure Forward | Site Map